Inside New York’s November Auction Week
It's auction week in New York. From Monday through Thursday, Sotheby's, Christie's and Bonhams are holding their November marquee sales, with up to $2.4 billion in art expected to change hands. Before each sale, the houses open their galleries to the public, and anyone can stand inches from works that may not be seen again for a generation.
I went down to the opening of the auction previews earlier this month to see the lots. I was lucky enough to be guided through the galleries by a member of each house, and got great insight on the collections. Here is what stayed with me, a look at the results so far, and a short guide to how it all works.
Sotheby's: Masterworks at the Breuer
Sotheby’s is holding its New York Sales from November 16 to 19 at the Breuer Building, its new headquarters on Madison Avenue. Of the three previews, it had the strongest lineup of masterworks.
The Impressionist works from Legendary: The Blaquier-Arrieta Collection, which sell tonight, were the emotional center for me, since Impressionism was my focus in art history. The collection includes Paul Cézanne's Arlequin, one of only four harlequin paintings by the artist, and a Pissarro view of the avenue de l'Opéra in winter sun, estimated at $30 to $40 million. There is also a Renoir, En Canot (1877), estimated at $25 to $35 million. Many of these works have been unseen for decades, and seeing them in one room felt like being in a museum gallery.
The postwar works were just as strong. Joan Mitchell's Green Book of Barbara Guest, from the Theodore and Ruth Baum collection, was one of my favorite paintings in the building, and it has already sold (more on that below). Edward Hopper's The Martha McKeen of Wellfleet (1944), estimated at $20 to $30 million, goes up tonight. It is a quiet Cape Cod scene any New Englander will feel at home with.
What ties these rooms together is provenance. Each top lot comes from a collector who lived with the work for decades. A work's history shapes its value as much as the canvas does.
Christie's: three collections, three stories
Christie's 20th Century Evening Sale took place last night, November 17, at Rockefeller Center. With 79 lots, it was the largest sale of the week, and walking its preview felt like moving through three private homes, one after another. The standout collections:
Herbert Lust spent a lifetime building friendships with artists, from Alberto Giacometti to Robert Indiana. He focused on artists with a Surrealist background , or those working in Surrealist modes. His collection reads like a memoir of those relationships.
Heroes and Lovers is a private collection of Picassos, a Manet and Old Masters, gathered around the great themes of devotion and myth.
Clive Davis chose his collection from the heart. Andy Warhol's Aretha, David Hockney and Joan Mitchell hang together as the picks of someone who spent his life recognizing talent.
Anchoring the evening were two paintings estimated at $60 to $80 million each: Wassily Kandinsky’s Betonte Ecken and Gustav Klimt’s Litzlbergkeller (1915), a lakeside landscape. Seeing the Klimt in person, with its shimmering surface, explains why his landscapes are among the most sought-after paintings in the market. Herbert Lust’s 1949 Giacometti, Figure, demie grandeur (no. 2), was offered with no reserve, meaning it would sell at whatever the room was willing to pay.
This is what I mean when I say art is your story. Each of these collections tells you who its owner was. That is the kind of collection I help my clients build.
Bonhams: a Brancusi moment
New York is having a Brancusi moment. His major exhibition is up at MoMA right now, and a few blocks away Bonhams is previewing Brancusi: The Legacy. The sale is five bronzes from a single private collection, all selling tonight, November 18.
Among them are the sleeping head, the abstracted portrait, and La jeune fille sophistiquée, his portrait of Nancy Cunard. It is rare to see so many of these forms gathered in one room, and to know they are all available.
There is one detail every collector should understand before bidding. These are posthumous casts, made from Brancusi's original models after his death in 1957. They are not lifetime casts, and that difference matters enormously for price. In May, his lifetime Danaïde set a record at Christie's at $107.6 million. The Bonhams estimates are in the millions, not the hundreds of millions. That is not a flaw in the works. It is simply part of their story, and knowing it is what lets you buy with confidence.
The Deans' Choice
The Bonhams evening sale also launches the Deans' Choice, created with Swizz Beatz and Alicia Keys so that living artists share in the resale of their work. Sellers choose to give the artist a percentage, and Bonhams matches it. As someone who loves connecting collectors with artists, I find this deeply encouraging. It recognizes that an artist's story does not end at the first sale.
The sale is led by a George Condo Big Face. Alongside it are a 1966 Willem de Kooning landscape, a Frank Stella, a Roy Lichtenstein and a Tamara de Lempicka. My favorite is a Matisse ink portrait of his muse Lydia, which has been in private hands for more than seventy years.
The results so far
Sotheby's, Monday night
Sotheby's opened the week on Monday night with two evening sales totaling $378.7 million with fees. The Baum collection sold all 24 of its lots for $109.9 million. In the Now and Contemporary sale, more than 60% of lots sold above their high estimates, led by Roy Lichtenstein's Reflections on "Painter and Model" at $24.6 million.
Joan Mitchell's Green Book of Barbara Guest sold for $19.3 million. The Baums bought it privately in 1986 for $65,000, a reminder of what patient, passionate collecting can become. Yayoi Kusama set a new auction record at $15.1 million, and records also fell for Sam Francis, Jonas Wood, Tomma Abts and Firelei Báez, whose Encyclopedia of Gestures sold for $1.13 million against a $600,000 to $800,000 estimate.
Christie's, Tuesday night
Christie’s 20th Century Evening Sale brought in $626.6 million with fees last night, with 88% of lots sold, well ahead of the $471.7 million the same sale made last November. Both of the evening’s headliners passed $80 million. The Kandinsky set a new record for the artist at $85.8 million, and the Klimt sold for $82.3 million. Its owner bought it at Sotheby’s in 1997 for under $15 million.
Herbert Lust's no-reserve Giacometti sold for $25.9 million, and his eight works together made $42 million. Heroes and Lovers, which was consigned by the artist Jeff Koons, made $104.7 million, although its Picasso, Le Baiser, fell short of its estimate at $31.1 million. Six artist records fell over the evening, including for Fernando Botero and Wifredo Lam. The auctioneer called the night "calibrated,"it was steady bidding rather than a frenzy.
Still to come
The week isn't over. Tonight, Bonhams offers Brancusi: The Legacy and its Deans' Choice evening sale, and Sotheby's holds Legendary: The Blaquier-Arrieta Collection and its Modern Evening Auction, with the Van Gogh, Pissarro, Renoir and Hopper. Sotheby's wraps up the week with its Modern Day Auction on Thursday morning.
How auctions work
Auctions are the art market's most public moment. Most art changes hands privately, but an auction result is published for everyone to see. That makes these sales the main benchmark for what an artist's work is worth, and they are how great collections return to circulation, often for the first time in a generation.
The process starts months before sale night, when a seller consigns a work. The house's specialists research it and agree with the seller on an estimate, the price range printed in the catalogue, and a reserve, a confidential minimum usually set at or below the low estimate. Important works often carry a guarantee, a promise from the house or an outside backer that the seller will receive a minimum price no matter what. A few, like the Lust Giacometti at Christie's, are offered with no reserve at all.
On sale night, bidders compete in the room, on the phone, online or through bids left in advance, and the auctioneer raises the price in set steps until the hammer falls. The winning bid is the hammer price, but it is not what the buyer pays. The house adds a buyer's premium on top: in New York, Sotheby's and Christie's now charge 28% on the first $2 million, 22% up to $8 million and 15% above that. A painting that hammers at $100,000 costs the buyer $128,000 before tax and shipping. Sellers pay a commission too, which is negotiable for the most sought-after works. The prices you read in the news include the premium, which is why a work can appear to beat its high estimate when the hammer actually fell within it.
What I took away
Three previews, three very different rooms, and one lesson running through all of them. The works that move us most, and that hold their value, are the ones with a story behind them. It might be a friendship with an artist, decades of living with a painting, or the way a sculpture was cast. I'll be following Bonhams and Sotheby's tonight and sharing the results on Instagram.
Auction previews are free and open to the public, and they are one of the best educations a collector can get. If you would like help understanding a lot, reading a condition report, or bidding with confidence, I would love to hear from you. You can book a consultation here or email me at hello@isabel-schuler.com.